Planning & Policy
The 2026 NPPF: what it changes for listed buildings
The new National Planning Policy Framework, published on 17 August 2026, renames the required document a Heritage Impact Assessment and rewrites the harm tests. What it means for owners, architects and agents.
The Government published a new National Planning Policy Framework on 17 August 2026. It replaces the December 2024 version and is the first complete rewrite since the Framework first appeared in 2012. For anyone working on a listed building, or on a site anywhere near one, the most immediate change is a change of name: the document that has to accompany an application is now called a Heritage Impact Assessment, and national policy says so. It also gives the heritage impact assessment an official name.
National planning policy is no longer a run of consecutively numbered paragraphs. It is a set of numbered policies, arranged by theme, and divided between plan-making and decision-making. The historic environment has moved from Chapter 16 to Chapter 20 and now runs as ten policies, HE1 to HE10. HE1 to HE3 are for local authorities preparing development plans. HE4 to HE10 are the policies against which applications are decided.
The change took effect at once. There is no transitional period for decision-making: the Framework confirms that its policies are material considerations from the day of publication. Anything submitted this week is being assessed against the new policies, and so is anything already sitting in a council’s system awaiting determination.
The Heritage Impact Assessment now has an official name
Annex C of the new Framework is new, and it is worth knowing about. It sets out, policy by policy, the information an applicant is expected to supply in support of an application. Against the heritage entry, and against policy HE5, it names one document: a heritage impact assessment, comprising an assessment of the significance of the assets affected, including any contribution made by their setting, and of the potential effects of the proposals on that significance.
Policy DM2 then requires local validation lists to include the information specified in Annex C, and limits councils to adding further requirements only where a development plan policy calls for a specific further assessment. The practical effect is that the Heritage Impact Assessment is becoming a nationally defined submission item rather than something every authority describes differently on its own list.
The old wording asked applicants to describe the significance of the assets affected. That is why a bare Statement of Significance could sometimes be argued to satisfy the requirement, and why so much submitted heritage material stopped short of assessing anything at all. HE5 closes that gap. Significance and effect are now a single required exercise, and the policy adds that decision-makers should be satisfied the assessment accurately reflects the effects of the proposals. The document is meant to be tested, not filed.
The harm scale has been rewritten
Policy HE5(2) requires an assessment to identify which of four outcomes a proposal is likely to produce:
- A positive effect, where the significance of the asset would be enhanced or better revealed.
- No effect on significance.
- Harm, whether from work to the asset itself or from development within its setting, with the degree of harm identified. Substantial harm is defined for the first time in national policy: it occurs where the proposal would seriously affect a key element of the asset’s significance.
- Total loss of significance.
Two phrases that have shaped heritage arguments for a decade or more have been removed from national policy altogether. The term less than substantial harm does not appear anywhere in the new Framework. Neither does optimum viable use. The lower band of harm survives as a concept, because harm is now graded against a defined ceiling, but the familiar label has gone.
One important principle survives untouched: it is the effect on significance, not the scale of the development, that matters. A small alteration to a sensitive interior can be more harmful than a large extension in the right place.
Weight, and where the balance sits
The term great weight, long the standard formula for the conservation of designated heritage assets, appears nowhere in the new document. Policy HE6 instead gives substantial weight to the conservation of a designated asset, the more important the asset the greater the weight. Historic England argued during the consultation that the substitution risked weakening protection and sitting awkwardly with the statutory duties. The final text retains substantial weight but adds that any harm to a designated asset is a matter of considerable importance and weight, which is the language the courts have used for years.
Below that, HE6 weighs harm against public benefits and, for the first time, names two of them: securing the long-term reuse of a vacant or underused listed building, and enabling energy efficiency and low carbon heating measures to be employed. The substantial harm test remains, with consent to be refused unless the harm is necessary to achieve substantial public benefits that outweigh it, or a narrow no-reasonable-use route is made out. Harm to a designated asset still requires a clear and convincing justification, and where there is evidence of deliberate neglect or damage, the deteriorated state of a building is not to count in the applicant’s favour.
The overall framing is more positive than it was. HE6 says that development which would have a positive effect on a designated heritage asset should be supported. That is an invitation to make the enhancement case openly rather than defensively.
Retrofit and reuse have a policy hook
This is the change most likely to alter outcomes on ordinary domestic work. Read alongside policy CC2, which gives substantial weight to the benefits of improving the energy efficiency of existing buildings, the retrofit argument has moved from good practice guidance into national policy on both sides of the planning balance.
Secondary glazing, insulation, a heat pump or the reuse of a long-empty building all now have a benefit that can be named and weighed. The corollary is that the benefit has to be evidenced. A claim that a scheme improves energy performance carries weight when it is specific about fabric and quantified. It carries very little when it is asserted in a sentence.
Unlisted buildings, local lists and conservation areas
Policy HE7 deals with non-designated heritage assets, which includes locally listed buildings and unlisted buildings that contribute to a conservation area. It now sets out three positions rather than one. A proposal with a positive effect should be supported. Harm is weighed against the benefits of the proposal, with a balanced judgement made having regard to the scale of harm and the significance of the asset. And, newly, where a proposal would cause substantial harm to or the total loss of a non-designated asset, it should only be supported where the harm is outweighed by the benefits.
Alongside that, HE1 expects development plans to be supported by a local heritage list identifying non-designated assets important to the local community. Coverage across England has always been patchy. As lists expand, more ordinary building stock will carry an identified heritage interest, and “it is not listed, so heritage does not apply” becomes a still less reliable assumption than it already was.
For conservation areas, HE9 asks that development retain and conserve buildings and features which make a positive contribution to character or appearance where possible, and that the area’s special architectural or historic interest, as identified as part of its designation, is considered in the design. Where an area was designated decades ago with a boundary and no character appraisal, there may be very little identified interest to point at, which puts the onus on the applicant’s assessment to establish the baseline properly.
What has not changed
The law. The Framework is policy, and it sits beneath the Planning (Listed Buildings and Conservation Areas) Act 1990. The duties in sections 16, 66 and 72, to have special regard to the desirability of preserving a listed building, its setting and its features of special interest, and to pay attention to preserving or enhancing the character or appearance of a conservation area, are untouched. Chapter 20 says expressly that its policies also relate to the consent regimes under that Act. Listed building consent is still required for the same works it was required for last week.
What to do now
- If you have an application awaiting determination, check that its heritage evidence reads against Chapter 20. The analysis in a recent report is unlikely to be wrong, but its policy section will now be out of date, and an objector or a conservation officer will say so.
- If a report is being commissioned, ask for a Heritage Impact Assessment, and expect it to grade the effect against the four outcomes in HE5.
- If the scheme delivers reuse or energy efficiency, get the evidence for it into the application rather than leaving the officer to infer it.
- Remember that appeals on applications dated on or after 1 April 2026 are largely decided on the material that was already before the council. The heritage evidence submitted with the application is, in effect, your appeal case.
Questions and answers
When did the new NPPF take effect?
It was published on 17 August 2026 and its policies became material considerations in decision-making from that day. There is no grace period for planning applications or listed building consent applications.
Does it apply to an application I have already submitted?
Yes. An application that has not yet been determined will be decided against the new policies, whatever policy framework the submitted documents were written against. If the scheme is finely balanced, a short addendum restating the assessment against policies HE5 and HE6 is usually worth the cost.
Do I need a Heritage Impact Assessment or a Heritage Impact Assessment?
A Heritage Impact Assessment. That is the term national policy now uses, and Annex C ties it to the information required in support of an application. In substance it is the assessment good practice already required: an assessment of the significance of the assets affected, including the contribution made by their setting, and of the effect of the proposals on that significance.
What happened to “less than substantial harm”?
The phrase has been removed from national policy. Harm is now graded against a defined ceiling instead, with substantial harm meaning development that would seriously affect a key element of an asset’s significance. Anything below that is simply harm, and the degree of it has to be identified and explained.
Does dropping “great weight” mean listed buildings are less protected?
Not on the face of the policy. The Framework has standardised its language of weight and uses substantial weight throughout, including for the conservation of designated heritage assets. It also states that any harm to a designated asset is a matter of considerable importance and weight, and the statutory duties in the 1990 Act are unchanged. How the shift in vocabulary plays out in decisions and appeals will become clearer over the coming months.
Is “optimum viable use” still a test?
No. The term has gone from national policy. Policy HE4 instead asks whether a proposal maintains or secures a use consistent with the conservation of the asset, taking into account the contribution the building can make to its local economy, character and distinctiveness.
Will the new Framework help with double glazing, insulation or a heat pump on a listed building?
It helps the argument, but it does not remove the need for consent or for a careful design. Energy efficiency and low carbon heating measures are now named as important public benefits capable of being weighed against harm, and improving the energy efficiency of existing buildings attracts substantial weight elsewhere in the Framework. The benefit still has to be evidenced, and harm still has to be minimised, so the detail of what is proposed matters as much as it ever did.
My building is not listed. Does any of this apply?
Possibly. If it is locally listed, on a local heritage list, or if it makes a positive contribution to a conservation area, it is a non-designated heritage asset and policy HE7 applies. That policy now has a substantial harm limb of its own, so proposals involving demolition or significant loss need to be assessed properly rather than assumed to be outside heritage policy.
My council has no conservation area appraisal and no local list. What difference does that make?
It does not prevent the council determining applications, and it does not mean heritage policy falls away. It does mean the council may have little documented evidence of what the special interest of the area actually is. In that situation a well-evidenced assessment submitted with the application often becomes the only analysis on the table, which is a good reason to prepare it properly and early.
Do I have to redo a report written a few weeks ago?
Usually not in full. The assessment of significance does not change because the policy has, and a sound report will still be a sound report. What needs revisiting is the policy section, the harm terminology and the conclusion, so that they are expressed in the language the decision-maker is now applying.
Where can I read the Framework?
It is free to download from gov.uk. It runs to 130 pages, with the historic environment chapter beginning at page 93, implementation at Annex A and the information requirements table at Annex C.
How we can help
Heritage Unlimited prepares Heritage Impact Assessments, setting assessments, historic building recording and listed building consent advice for owners, architects and planning agents across England. If you have an application in the system and are not sure how the new policies affect it, or you are commissioning heritage evidence for a scheme now, we are happy to talk it through.
Get in touch or call 0330 0880 984.
In this article
Get in touch
Tell us about your project. We’ll tell you what’s involved.
A short conversation is usually enough to confirm what’s needed, what it costs, and how the work is best routed. Most enquiries receive an outline approach within 24 hours.
To get a fast outline approach, share:
- The address of the property and its grading, if known
- A short description of the proposed works
- Where you are in the planning process
- Your role: owner, developer, architect, or public body
